Pinoy Idol

the pinoy idol is sooooo lousy. the contestants are lousy, gma’s sound system is lousy and so are the judges. i was hoping that we could have credible judges who know what music is and not just people who can barely sing like jolina m. how come they dont look sincere when they give comments to the contestants? i dont like this show. i like regine’s pinoy pop superstar more and her music jury. come up with some perks people, your show is so boring……raymond gutierez can put me to sleep……too bad ogie is with the crowd.

Sincerely …after watching American Idol and still have the hang of the finals and then shifting to Pinoy Idol to watch…i was totally… speechless.. i must agree with Sarah..your show couldnt live up to American Idol and the Philippine Idol version of channel 5…so very boring…there’s no zing..there’s lacking something..no Ooomph!

The judges are… i dont know… they ‘re great in their own fields but i dont think they’re right to become an idol judge. Dont get me wrong..but it makes me sad to see this..the stage is so cheap..so does the sound system..c’mon you came all the way to signing the contract and franchise..why dont you make it a big budgeted tv series…go to a bigger stage like the American Idol’s.

Look at Channel 2’s Big Brother..they’re studio is not cheap they even go beyond the requirement of the original Big Brother’s. Yeah it’s true.. Regine’s Pinoy Pop Superstar is far more better than Pinoy Idol. I like Raymond’s hosting job but not in Pinoy Idol… parang tinatamad kayo guys..are you tired? Get some break. The Judges…maybe it would be better if you get Leah Salonga, Regine Velasquez, Kuh Ledesma, Gary Valenciano, Ryan Cayabyab those people who have international recognitions…

Hope the management will look into this… the intro …the advertising of Pinoy Idol is great but when you watch it… it doesnt even come close to American Idol…. i hate to say this..but if you dont come up with better ideas..it will become a “Pinoy Flop”. Sorry truth hurts. Im a kapuso…im just a concerned viewer.

I was a Philippine Idol fan and I can’t help but get disappointed. No energy. The judges don’t cut it at all.

I agree with you that it will be PINOY FLOP. I wonder if they can make use of the old Philippine Idol production staff.

can we make a request to GMA 7 and Channel 11? can we have a rerun, replay, a repeat of American Idol instead?

one thing more…i am not an expert in singing but it doesnt take an expert to recognize if a person is out of tune…but you guys still sugar coat your comments to the contestants…make up your mind guys! You should talk and plan, all 3 judges… one of you should be like Medium commentator like Jackson, a sweet commnetator like Paula and a sharp tounge like Simon. I ‘ve watched the episode where you guys bombarded one contestant with harsh words. It’s like its getting personal or you must be all tired..but hope you’d still be professional and not act like a bunch of college musical teachers from some cheap school.

Sorry cant get enough of American Idol… cant get over them yet… and seeing Pinoy Idol makes me sick…sorry guys for the unkind words… I always support your shows..but not on this one…soweee… I dont know how you can remedy this..but I’m still hoping it’s not yet doomed (sigh).